Which one is which
The Morpeth is the smart one: a structured full grain flap that closes on a solid brass push-lock, plus a top grab handle so it can be carried like a briefcase into a meeting. The Leyburn is the rugged one: thick buffalo leather with an oiled pull-up finish and a flap held by two buckled straps. It looks broken-in within a month. The Penrith is the light one, at 2.4 lb empty. Its waxed canvas sheds rain, and the strap, trim and base are full grain leather, which makes it the bag for a wet commute or a bike.
Side by side
| Morpeth | Leyburn | Penrith |
| Material | Full grain leather | Full grain buffalo leather | 18 oz waxed canvas, leather trim |
| Size | 15.5" x 11.5" x 4" | 15.5" x 11.5" x 4" | 15.5" x 11.5" x 4" |
| Laptop | 15-inch, padded sleeve | 15-inch, padded sleeve | 15-inch, padded sleeve |
| Closure | Brass push-lock | Two buckled straps | Two buckled straps |
| Top handle | Yes | No | No |
| Empty weight | 3.1 lb | 3.1 lb | 2.4 lb |
| Colors | Black, chocolate, cognac, olive, tan | Black, chocolate, cognac, oxblood, tan | Five canvas and leather pairings |
| Price | $215 | $235 | $185 |
How to choose a men's messenger bag
Start with the laptop. All three take a 15-inch laptop in a padded sleeve. For a 16-inch machine, go to the Durham in men's leather satchels. Next, think about the commute. In a city with a lot of rain, or on a bike, the Penrith is the practical choice. If you walk into client meetings, the Morpeth's clean flap and push-lock look the most formal. If you are hard on bags and like them to show it, choose the Leyburn. Last, decide on the closure: a push-lock is quicker, while buckles stretch a little further when the bag is packed full.
Sizing for a man's frame
A 15.5-inch messenger is the natural size for most men. It is wide enough for a full-size laptop but not so wide that it swings into people on a crowded train. At 4 inches deep it lies flat under an overcoat. The strap adjusts to a 23-inch drop, so on a tall man the bag still sits at the hip when worn across the body. Shorten it if you prefer to carry the bag on one shoulder.
Messenger or satchel?
A messenger is carried on its strap. A satchel adds a short top handle, so it doubles as a briefcase. The Morpeth sits between the two. The Durham is a true satchel, with two compartments for people who carry more, and the Hebden is a lighter 15-inch satchel with a front pocket, for a 14-inch laptop. See men's leather satchels, or our leather briefcases for handle-first bags.
What to check on any men's messenger bag
Start with where the strap meets the bag: it should be stitched and riveted through doubled leather, not glued to a thin tab. Check that the laptop sleeve is padded and separate from the main section. Look at the hardware, because solid brass does not flake the way plated zinc does. Read the leather grade closely: "genuine leather" and "bonded leather" are lower grades, and full grain is the top. Our guide to the best leather for bags explains every grade. Finally, look at the edges: burnished edges last, while painted edges peel.
Colors for men
Black is the most formal and goes with everything. Chocolate and cognac go with brown shoes and a navy suit. Tan starts light and darkens fastest, so pick it if you want a bag that looks lived-in. Olive, on the Morpeth, reads as brown indoors and green in daylight. Oxblood, on the Leyburn, is a deep red-brown that shows the buffalo grain best.
As a gift
A messenger bag is one of the most common leather gifts for a new job, a graduation or a third anniversary, which is the leather anniversary. Initials are pressed free, and a blind press is the most popular choice on men's bags, because they show only in the right light. See graduation gifts for him, 3rd anniversary gifts for him and our article on 3rd anniversary gift ideas for him.
Made to order and returns
Each messenger is cut and stitched by hand in our own workshop after you order, and leaves within 5 to 7 working days. You can return it within 30 days, initials or not. We cover the stitching for life and the hardware for five years. See our warranty.
Related
Read our guide to the best leather messenger bags for men. You can also browse leather laptop messenger bags or men's crossbody bags for lighter days, go back to all leather messenger bags, or see every men's leather bag.