Our duffles side by side
| Barnard | Keswick | Malton | Helmsley | Ilkley |
| Material | Full grain leather | 18 oz waxed canvas, full grain leather handles and base | Full grain buffalo leather | Smooth full grain leather | Crazy horse leather |
| Size (W x H x D) | 21" x 12" x 10" | 20" x 12" x 10" | 21" x 12" x 10" | 24" x 13" x 11" | 18" x 11" x 9" |
| Packs | 2 to 3 nights | 2 to 3 nights plus shoes in the end pocket | 2 to 4 nights | 3 to 5 nights plus shoes | 1 to 2 nights |
| Carry | Rolled handles (10" drop), detachable shoulder strap | Rolled handles (10" drop), detachable shoulder strap | Rolled handles, shoulder strap | Flat handles, strap on swivel clips | Rolled handles, shoulder strap, trolley sleeve |
| Inside | Long zip pocket, two open pockets | Zip pocket, two open pockets, zipped shoe pocket at one end | Zip pocket, two open pockets, end zip pocket | Zip pocket, two open pockets, zipped shoe compartment | Zip wall pocket, front zip pocket |
| Empty weight | 4.4 lb | 3.1 lb | 4.6 lb | 5.3 lb | 3.3 lb |
| Colors | Black, chocolate, cognac, olive, tan | Five canvas and leather pairings | Black, chocolate, tan | Black, chocolate, cognac | Black, chocolate, olive, tan |
| Price | $295 | $235 | $285 | $295 | $245 |
Which duffle for which trip
Choose the Barnard if the bag is also a statement: an anniversary trip, a wedding weekend or the one big gift. Full grain leather takes knocks, darkens into a patina and is the bag people ask about. Choose the Keswick if you travel by car or train, pack wet boots, or want to save weight. It is 1.3 lb lighter, sheds rain, and its zipped end pocket keeps shoes or a damp towel away from your clothes. Choose the Malton if you are hard on bags: thick buffalo leather with a pull-up finish, brass feet and room for up to four nights. Choose the Helmsley for a week away by car or train, with shoes in their own compartment. Choose the Ilkley for one or two nights, riding on top of a wheeled case.
Duffle, weekender or holdall?
The words overlap. A duffle is a soft, zip-top bag with two carry handles. A weekender is a duffle sized for two or three nights, like the Barnard and Keswick. A holdall is the British word for the same thing, often a little larger, like our 24-inch Helmsley. See our leather weekender bags for packing a weekend, or all our leather travel bags, including dopp kits and a backpack.
Will it fit as a carry-on?
US airlines commonly allow a carry-on of about 22 x 14 x 9 inches including handles. The 18 x 11 x 9-inch Ilkley sits inside that limit. The Barnard, Keswick and Malton are 20 to 21 inches wide and 12 inches tall, and because they are soft-sided they squash into most overhead lockers once packed. At 10 inches deep, a full bag can be a little deeper than a strict sizer, so leave some slack on budget airlines that measure. The 24-inch Helmsley is too big for most cabins and is a bag to check or keep in the car. None of them fits under the seat.
What fits inside
For two nights you can pack two shirts, a sweater, a spare pair of trousers, underwear and socks, a wash bag and a pair of shoes. For three nights, roll your clothes and wear the bulkiest shoes. A dopp kit keeps liquids apart from your clothes. If you fly, carry liquids of 3.4 oz or less in a quart-size clear bag.
What to check on any leather duffle
The handles carry everything, so they should be wrapped and stitched through to the body, not glued. The base takes the most wear and should be a second layer of leather or a sturdy panel. The strap clips should be solid metal, not plated zinc. A two-way zip is easier to open when the bag is full. And the leather should be full grain, the strongest grade, because thin corrected leather cracks at the folds of a soft bag. Our article on the best leather for bags explains the grades.
Leather or waxed canvas for travel
Full grain leather is stronger and more formal, and it gets better with scuffs. It is also heavier, and it wants to dry slowly if it is caught in a downpour, as explained in can leather get wet. Waxed canvas weighs less, shrugs off rain and is easy to clean, and on the Keswick every part that takes wear is full grain leather. See all our waxed canvas bags and full grain leather bags.
Care on the road
Pack the duffle loosely rather than forcing the zip, and stuff it with paper between trips so it keeps its shape. Wipe leather dry and condition it twice a year. Re-wax canvas when water stops beading. More in how to care for leather bags and how to clean a leather bag.
As a gift
A leather duffle with initials pressed on the end is one of the most-asked-for gifts for a third anniversary, a groom or a retirement. See leather gifts for him, groomsmen gifts and 3rd anniversary gifts for him.
Made to order and returns
Every duffle is cut and stitched by hand in our own workshop after you order and leaves within 5 to 7 working days. We press up to three initials free, in gold, silver or a blind press. Any bag can come back within 30 days, and the stitching is covered for life. See shipping and delivery and returns and exchanges.
Further reading
Compare styles in the best leather duffle bags and the best travel handbags, or see all men's leather bags.