Leather Guide

Roll Top Leather Backpack Pros and Cons: Is One Right for You?

A roll top leather backpack grows with what you carry, keeps rain out well and ages beautifully, but it is slower to open and heavier than nylon. This guide weighs the pros and cons against a zip backpack, with real sizes and tips for living with one.

Two roll top leather backpacks on a cream background: a black cowhide roll top with one strap and a chocolate brown buffalo leather roll top with two straps

By The Bag n Fable workshopUpdated 10 min read

A roll top leather backpack is worth it if you want one bag that changes size with your day, keeps out rain better than a zip and looks smart in an office. Its downsides are slower access to the main compartment, extra height when you unroll it, and the weight and care that come with leather. A good design fixes most of the access problem with a side or front zip, so the real question is whether you value flexibility and looks more than speed and low weight.

This guide sets out the pros and cons in detail, compares a roll top with a zip backpack, and explains what to look for in a leather one. We make two roll top leather backpacks, which appear in small boxes, but the advice applies to any brand.

Disclosure: We are a leather bag workshop. The product boxes show our own backpacks, with prices as listed in November 2026.

Roll top leather backpack pros and cons at a glance

Pros Cons
Capacity Grows by 3 to 6 inches when unrolled, about 20 to 30% more room Gets taller when full, which can be awkward for short people
Weather The folded top keeps rain and dust out better than a zip Not waterproof: seams and leather still let water in under a downpour
Access Wide opening for bulky things like a jacket or a box Slower to open, and you dig down from the top
Security Hard to open quietly from behind Small outside pockets are still easy targets
Looks Clean front, no long zip, works with a suit The roll looks untidy if you roll it badly
Durability No main zip to break; leather lasts decades The fold line needs conditioning to avoid cracks
Weight Thick leather keeps its shape Heavier than nylon, about 3 to 4 lb empty

What is a roll top backpack?

A roll top backpack has an open mouth instead of a zip across the top. You fold the top edge down two or three times, then hold the roll with a strap and buckle, or with clips at the sides. Roll it more times and the bag is shorter and tighter; roll it fewer times and you get more room. The design comes from bike couriers and dry bags used on boats, where a folded seal keeps water out better than any zip.

A black leather roll top backpack rolled down and unrolled, next to a chocolate brown buffalo leather roll top opened wide
Rolled down for less, unrolled for more

In leather the idea works a little differently. Leather is too stiff to roll as tightly as coated fabric, so leather roll tops are usually rolled two or three times and fastened with a long strap down the front. That strap and its buckle become the main feature of the design.

The pros of a roll top leather backpack

1. It grows and shrinks with your day

This is the main reason to choose one. A roll top can carry a laptop and a lunch on Monday, then a laptop, a jacket and a bottle of wine on Friday. Our Malham, for example, stands 17 inches tall rolled and 21 inches unrolled, which takes it from about 18 to 23 liters. A zip backpack is the same size every day: too big when you carry little, too small when you need more.

2. It keeps weather out better than a zip

When the top is rolled down twice, water has to climb up and over two folds to get in. A zip, even a good one, has a line of teeth that lets rain through. Full grain leather also sheds a light shower on its own. That makes a roll top the better choice for walking and cycling commutes in a rainy city.

It is not waterproof. In a downpour, water can soak into leather and seep through stitching. Blot it dry and let it dry slowly at room temperature, and it will be fine. Our guide can leather get wet explains what to do.

3. The opening is wide

Unroll the top and the whole bag opens. A box, a folded jacket or a bag of shopping goes in without fighting a zip. That also makes a roll top easy to pack neatly, because you can see to the bottom.

4. There is no main zip to fail

Zips are the most common thing to break on a backpack, and a broken main zip ends a bag’s life. A roll top has a buckle and a strap, both of which last for years and can be repaired by any cobbler.

5. It looks clean and grown-up

With no long zip across the front and no clips, a leather roll top has a simple, almost architectural shape. It looks right with a suit or a smart coat, which is why it has become a popular work backpack.

The cons of a roll top leather backpack

1. It is slower to get into

To reach the main compartment you unbuckle the strap, unroll the top and then dig down. That takes ten or fifteen seconds, which is nothing on a quiet morning and annoying at an airport security tray. The fix is a second way in: a side zip that reaches the laptop sleeve, or a front pocket for the things you need often. Without one, a roll top is a poor work bag.

2. Things sink to the bottom

A roll top is one tall compartment. Small things fall to the base, under your laptop and lunch. Pouches help, and so does packing in layers, with the things you need least at the bottom.

3. It gets taller when full

Unroll a roll top and it can grow by 4 to 6 inches. On a person with a shorter back, the top may rise above the shoulders or the base may drop below the hips. If you are petite, choose a roll top that is no more than 17 inches tall rolled down.

4. Leather is heavier than nylon

A leather roll top weighs about 3 to 4 lb empty, against 1 to 2 lb for a nylon one. You feel it on a long walk, and less on a commute. In return you get a bag that keeps its shape and lasts for many years.

5. The fold line needs care

Every time you roll a leather top, it bends in the same place. Without conditioning that line can dry and crack after a few years. A thin layer of leather balm on the fold twice a year prevents it.

Roll top vs zip backpack

Roll top Zip top
Capacity Adjustable, grows when unrolled Fixed
Rain Better: folded seal Weaker: rain gets through the teeth
Quick access Slower, unless there is a side zip Faster
Organization One deep compartment Easier to add pockets and dividers
Security Hard to open quietly A zip can be opened from behind
Looks Clean, simple front Depends on the design
Repairs Strap and buckle are easy to fix A broken zip needs a workshop
Best for Walking and cycling commutes, variable loads, weekends Flights, meetings, people who open their bag often

Many people find the best answer is both: a roll top with a zip somewhere on it. Our two roll tops each have one. The Malham has a side zip to the laptop sleeve; the Gunnerside has a full zipped compartment under the roll and a large front zip pocket.

Is a roll top leather backpack good for work?

Yes, if it has a side zip or a front pocket for the things you reach for in a meeting. Look for a padded laptop sleeve raised off the base, a short top handle for carrying it into a room, and a base that stands up on its own when the bag is half empty. In black, chocolate or navy, a leather roll top looks as smart as a briefcase. See our leather work backpacks for more options.

Is a roll top leather backpack good for travel?

For short trips, very. A roll top that is 18 inches tall rolled down fits most cabin limits, then grows on the way home for the things you bought. A trolley sleeve and a zipped compartment under the roll make it much easier to live with at an airport. For long flights where the bag stays under the seat, a slim zip backpack is quicker to dip into. Our guide to the best travel backpacks for women compares styles by trip, and our leather travel backpacks include both roll tops.

Cowhide or buffalo leather?

Full grain cowhide Full grain buffalo leather
Feel Smooth, fine and even grain Thick, bold natural grain
Scuffs Show a little, then blend into the patina Hide almost completely
Weight Lighter Heavier
Best for Office, smart casual, smaller frames Travel, heavy loads, outdoors

Cowhide gives a sleeker roll and a more polished look. Buffalo leather is tougher and more forgiving, and the roll holds its shape better under a heavy load. Either should be full grain, which keeps the natural surface of the hide; our guide full grain vs top grain leather explains why that matters.

What to look for in a roll top leather backpack

  • A second way in. A side zip or a zipped compartment under the roll.
  • Full grain leather of about 1.4 to 2 mm, thick enough to hold a roll and stand up.
  • Solid brass buckles. Plated buckles flake; solid brass just darkens.
  • A padded laptop sleeve that fits your laptop with its case.
  • A height that suits your back. About 17 inches rolled for most women, up to 18 to 19 inches for taller people.
  • Stitching that is even and tight, especially where the straps meet the body.

How to roll and pack it properly

Load the heaviest things first and closest to your back, the laptop in its sleeve and shoes or a wash bag at the base. Fill the middle with soft things and push the air out. Fold the top down at least twice, keeping the fold straight, then pull the strap snug so the roll sits flat against the front. If your bag has an inner zip, close it first. Keep keys, cards and your phone in the outside pocket, so you rarely need to unroll during the day.

Caring for a leather roll top

Wipe the bag with a dry cloth every few weeks. Condition the whole bag once or twice a year, and the fold line a little more often, with a thin layer of balm; keep it off the buckles. After rain, unroll the top and let the bag dry open at room temperature, never on a radiator. Store it unrolled and lightly stuffed with tissue, so the fold has a rest. Our guide how to clean a leather bag covers marks and stains.

Our roll tops are made to order and dispatched in 5 to 7 working days, with free initials. Browse all our roll top leather backpacks, or see our returns and exchanges policy.

Frequently asked questions

Are roll top backpacks worth it?

Yes, if you carry different amounts on different days or walk and cycle in the rain. If you open your bag dozens of times a day, a zip backpack is quicker.

Are leather roll top backpacks waterproof?

No, but they are weather resistant. The folded top keeps out rain better than a zip, and full grain leather sheds light showers. In a downpour, water can soak in through the leather and seams.

How many times should you roll a roll top backpack?

At least twice. One roll does not seal the top or hold its shape; two or three rolls keep rain out and let the strap sit flat.

Do roll top backpacks hold more than zip backpacks?

They hold more when unrolled, often 20 to 30% more than when rolled down. A zip backpack of the same rolled size holds about the same on an ordinary day.

Is a roll top backpack annoying to use?

Only if it has no other way in. With a side zip or a front pocket for everyday things, you rarely need to unroll it during the day.

Can a roll top backpack go in the overhead bin?

Yes. Rolled down, most leather roll tops fit cabin limits. Unrolled and full, they may be too tall for strict airlines, so roll them down before boarding.

Are roll top backpacks secure?

The main compartment is hard to open from behind without you noticing, because someone would need to unbuckle and unroll it. Outside pockets are less secure, so keep valuables inside.

How long does a leather roll top backpack last?

With conditioning once or twice a year, full grain leather lasts for decades. The strap and buckle can be replaced by a cobbler, so the bag rarely has a single point of failure.

Similar Posts